The lawyer for Sanjay Roy, who has been arrested in the rape and murder case of a trainee doctor in Kolkata, asserts that the evidence against him is not substantial. Kabita Sarkar, Roy’s lawyer, claims that CCTV footage alone cannot definitively prove Roy’s guilt. She also accuses the CBI and Kolkata police of not providing adequate support.
According to Sarkar, Roy has not disclosed any names and maintains that he wants a polygraph test to prove his innocence. Sarkar describes Roy as distressed and under significant pressure, having admitted to police that he knew of the crime scene but later recanted his statement during the polygraph test.
Key Points:
- Accused’s Statement: Roy initially confessed to the police but changed his statement during the polygraph test, claiming he saw the victim’s body but fled the scene.
- Legal Proceedings: Roy was presented in court on August 10 and remains in police custody. His lawyer, Kabita Sarkar, was appointed on August 22 after several lawyers declined to take the case due to public backlash.
- CCTV Footage: Sarkar argues that CCTV footage alone is insufficient to prove guilt, questioning the reliability of the footage and the investigation’s thoroughness.
- Polygraph Test: Roy reportedly broke down in court when asked for consent to the polygraph test, expressing his desire to clear his name.
- Hospital Environment: Concerns have been raised about the security and operational practices at the hospital where the crime occurred, with allegations that Roy used to influence admissions for monetary gains.
Investigative Issues:
- CBI and Kolkata Police: Sarkar alleges that the CBI has not provided necessary documents and has limited her access to critical information. She also criticizes the Kolkata police for their alleged lack of impartiality.
- Forensic Evidence: The forensic examination of the victim’s body has been criticized for procedural lapses, and the investigation has been hampered by inconsistencies in the crime scene recreation.
Additional Developments:
- Seizures and Investigations: Kolkata police have seized 53 items related to the case, including Roy’s clothing and bike. The Enforcement Directorate (ED) is also investigating former Medical College Principal Sandeep Ghosh for financial irregularities based on CBI’s FIR.
Protests and Public Response:
- Ongoing Protests: Demonstrations continue across the country demanding justice and improved security measures at medical facilities. Activists are calling for increased CCTV surveillance and better protection for medical staff and students.